Gooey Butter Cake from 52Teas

Tea Information:

Leaf Type:  Black

Where To Buy:  52Teas

Tea Description:

Thanks to Azzrian for the idea for this blend. I actually think my wife is a little upset she didn’t think of it first. She makes an awesome gooey butter cake.

My wife is fond of telling people that she has no idea how I manage to make such amazing teas since my cooking skills are more or less limited to ramen noodles and microwave popcorn. Likewise, I have no idea what sort of magic she employs in creating a gooey butter cake. Yes, I could look at one of several recipes for gooey butter cake, but I prefer to believe it is magic, because a gooey butter cake (for those of you who have never had one), is one of those beautiful things that shouldn’t be discussed in such muggle terms as a recipe. It’s way better to have someone make one for you and assume they possess magical gifts.

Learn more about this tea here.

Taster’s Review:

Oh.  My.  Goodness.

This is so good.

I love Gooey Butter Cake.  It is one of my guilty pleasures.  On the occasions when I shop at WalMart, I always go to the bakery section, and look for Paula Deen’s baked goods, and hope that they will have her Lemon Gooey Butter Cake.  They are similar to lemon bars (you know those incredible bar cookies that have a shortbread crust, and a sweet and tangy lemon-curd like filling?  Yeah, those), only the Lemon Gooey Butter Cake is better because it is not only lemon-y like the lemon bars, but it is rich with buttery goodness, and has a gooey consistency that can only be compared to the joy of licking out the cake batter bowl.

I’m fairly certain that these Gooey Butter Cakes are not considered healthy.  But what they lack in nutritional value they make up for in pure culinary happiness.

So when 52Teas announced Gooey Butter Cake flavored black tea as their tea of the week for September 17, I did the happy dance.  I could have my gooey butter cake and have tea too?  And without all the fat and calories of the gooey butter cake?  This sounds almost too good to be true.

When I opened the pouch, I couldn’t believe my nose!  It smelled so incredible.  It smelled buttery and sweet, with hints of lemon.  At that point, I could hardly wait for my Breville One-Touch to brew the tea … and this thing brews tea fast!  I stood over the tea maker, waiting for it to finally finish.  It seemed much longer than the three or so minutes.

The brewed tea smells very much like the dry leaf, it smells sweet and buttery, like freshly baked cake, with hints of lemon. And that’s exactly what I taste, too!  I don’t know that this tastes EXACTLY like Gooey Butter Cake, but, it is probably as close to the real thing that tea is ever going to get.

The black tea base is rich and smooth, and it’s the perfect base for the flavors of freshly baked gooey butter cake.  There is a kiss of lemon flavor in there, just enough to brighten the flavors.  This is sinful indulgence in a teacup.  The only thing that might make it better is chocolate.  But, to be honest, I’ve tried Paula Deen’s Chocolate Gooey Butter Cake, and I wasn’t all that impressed.  So… maybe chocolate wouldn’t make this better after all.  Maybe it’s perfectly magical, just the way it is.


Co-Founder/Co-Creator of SororiTea Sisters, Mad Tea Artist at 52Teas
Anne (aka the Mad Tea Artist) has celebrated her 29th birthday for many years now. She lives in the Pacific Northwest with her hubby and her youngest daughter. Her oldest daughter is married and has bestowed Anne with the proud title of "Gramma" and her grandson is about the cutest boy you ever did see.

Anne started her journey with tea as a casual drinker and became more serious about her tea drinking when she realized that she couldn't drink coffee. Shortly thereafter, she started becoming obsessed with the beverage and she started creating small-batch, artisan blends of tea that she sold online as LiberTEAS. After a few years, she realized she wasn't cut out to be the sole proprietor of a business so she closed LiberTEAS and started reviewing teas online. She met Jennifer through another blog that they both reviewed for and they decided to start their own review blog. This review blog!

Throughout her journey as a tea reviewer, she discovered 52Teas and became enamored with the idea of creating a new tea every week. When the founder of 52Teas decided he wanted to move on, he offered the business to Anne but knowing that she wasn't cut out to be a sole proprietor, she instead offered the company to her oldest daughter who employs her as the Mad Tea Artist for 52Teas!

Latest posts by liberteas (see all)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *