Cupcake from Old Wilmington Tea Co.

Tea Information:

Leaf Type:  Black

Where to Buy:  Old Wilmington Tea Co.

Company Description:

Who can resist a cupcake? Treat yourself every day with our yummy blend of black tea, natural vanilla & caramel flavor with fun colorful sprinkles mixed in! A celebration in your teacup!

Taster’s Review:

This is definitely a celebration in a teacup!

Ahh… a cupcake!  Is there any dessert that elicits more child-like delight than a cupcake?  I – being of strong sweet tooth – love cupcakes.  I’m sure that probably comes as no surprise to any of you who have read many of my reviews!  But, I must admit, my love of cupcakes is somewhat of an obsession.

So when I found this tea as I was browsing Old Wilmington’s website, I knew I had to try it.   Fortunately, Old Wilmington offers generously sized sample packages, super fast shipping, and very courteous service.

The black tea base used for this blend is very robust.  Although Old Wilmington does not reveal what black tea they use for this tea, I suspect that it is a blend that contains Assam, if not made entirely of Assam.  My reason for believing this is that this is a very strong, malty tasting tea and you just don’t really get that from an average, everyday Ceylon.  Yes, occasionally you might find a Ceylon that can pack this kind of punch, but, it doesn’t happen often.  Whatever the tea in this base, it brews to a very stout, delicious liquor.

I don’t know that what I’m tasting here in my cup actually tastes like a cupcake.  I can taste a deliciously decadent caramel flavoring, as well as a creamy vanilla note.  That creamy note is further enhanced by the addition of milk or cream, which I did add, to make it a latte.  I tried it first without the milk, but I do think that it is much better with it.  The milk gives it a real smooth, rich flavor that makes a very good cup quite extraordinary.

I strongly recommend to anyone who is trying this tea for the first time to experiment with your steeping time.  I recommend starting out at just 2 or 2 1/2 minutes.  The first time I brewed it, I brewed it for 3 minutes and quickly learned (within moments following my first sip) that this was too long.  The tea can take on a slightly bitter taste when brewed too long… and nobody wants a bitter cupcake, am I right?

Despite an unsuccessful first attempt (well, it wasn’t really unsuccessful, it just was slightly bitter, but not undrinkable), I will say that this is one “cupcake” that is worth the effort of finding the right time for your perfect cup of tea.  (I found that 2 1/2 minutes is just perfect for me)   It is a delightful treat any time of day, a great way to indulge without consuming a lot of extra calories (let’s face it, cupcakes do taste good, but they aren’t particularly waistline friendly, are they?)  Even adding just a teaspoon of sugar and a splash of milk to your cup to enhance the vanilla and caramel flavors only adds a fraction of the calories than consuming a cupcake.


Co-Founder/Co-Creator of SororiTea Sisters, Mad Tea Artist at 52Teas
Anne (aka the Mad Tea Artist) has celebrated her 29th birthday for many years now. She lives in the Pacific Northwest with her hubby and her youngest daughter. Her oldest daughter is married and has bestowed Anne with the proud title of "Gramma" and her grandson is about the cutest boy you ever did see.

Anne started her journey with tea as a casual drinker and became more serious about her tea drinking when she realized that she couldn't drink coffee. Shortly thereafter, she started becoming obsessed with the beverage and she started creating small-batch, artisan blends of tea that she sold online as LiberTEAS. After a few years, she realized she wasn't cut out to be the sole proprietor of a business so she closed LiberTEAS and started reviewing teas online. She met Jennifer through another blog that they both reviewed for and they decided to start their own review blog. This review blog!

Throughout her journey as a tea reviewer, she discovered 52Teas and became enamored with the idea of creating a new tea every week. When the founder of 52Teas decided he wanted to move on, he offered the business to Anne but knowing that she wasn't cut out to be a sole proprietor, she instead offered the company to her oldest daughter who employs her as the Mad Tea Artist for 52Teas!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *